This shingle Gambrel-style waterfront home on Shelter Island offers unobstructed views of West Neck Harbor and Noyac Bay. Available for the first time in nearly 12 years following a complete renovation, it is asking $5.3 million. Located on about a half-acre in the Montclair Colony community, on the south side of the island, the 4,900-square-foot … Continue reading Newly Renovated Waterfront Home With Private Dock on Shelter Island Asks $5.3 Million