Shelter Island

Peter McCracken, an associate broker with the Corcoran Group, knows the Shelter Island real estate market. He has been selling properties there for 32 years, and even broke a record for the highest sale there that stood for nearly 15 years.

A century and a half of history and an artistic pedigree come together on the Shelter Island Heights waterfront, once known as Divinity Hill.

Shelter Island, accessible only by ferry, offers a unique real estate market, with prices topping out at $20 million.

If this Shelter Island property sells for its $15.495 million asking price, or close to it, it would beat the island’s record for the most expensive sale.

A fully furnished luxury home located at 18 Dickerson Drive on Shelter Island has hit the market for $2,495,000.

A midcentury A-frame at 7 Marc Street on Shelter Island, now on the market for $1.8 million, has been renovated into a stylish and serene retreat.

A Heiberg Cummings Design, this luxurious Shelter Island home is an architectural masterpiece, Stacey Cohen of Saunders & Associates says.

A classic grand colonial along the water on Shelter Island’s Dering Harbor listed recently for $8 million.

A nearly nine-acre property is already a private compound that even has a horse stable, but there is potential for even more on this estate, known as Lady’s Legacy. Plus, it’s close to town on the exclusive island.

A new Shelter Island exclusive on a peninsula in Coecles Harbor hit the market this week with Penelope Moore of Saunders & Associates.