Top Five Sag Harbor Sanctuaries for Under $3.5 Million

Bay Street Theater, Sag Harbor Cinema, highly rated restaurants, beautiful bay beaches and harbors, unique shops—what more reasons do you need to live in Sag Harbor? This quintet of properties for $3.5 million or less is just a taste of the current enticing real estate offerings in Sag Harbor.

2 Carver Street, Sag Harbor. $3,250,000 cully/eefas
2 Carver Street, $3,250,000
Photo credit: Cully/EEFAS

This 4,400-square foot modern farmhouse fully renovated and designed by International Interior Designers sits on 0.57 acres. The residence has four bedrooms, each with an ensuite bathroom, and one half-bath. The living space is open concept with high vaulted loft ceilings and hardwood floors. The gourmet kitchen with high-end appliances has Calcutta marble countertops. On the lower level find a media den, a dining area and space for gaming tables. The grounds feature a heated gunite pool and outdoor shower.

19 Notre Dame, $3,500,000

This waterfront beach cottage with a 220-foot wraparound bulkhead on a peninsula in the Redwood neighborhood offers three bedrooms, two full bathrooms and a half-bath. The open living and dining area has cathedral ceilings and a fireplace. Enjoy a modern kitchen and a television room in this 2,200-square-foot house. The 0.29-acre property features low-maintenance gardens, a cherry tree, spacious decking and outdoor shower and a 55-foot dock.

44 John Street, $3,500,000

Built in 1880, this well maintained historic whaler’s house with frontage on Sag Harbor Cove sits on 0.21 acres and has four bedrooms and two-and-a-half bathrooms. The house’s mechanicals have been upgrades while many original design details are intact. The 2,450 square feet of living space—plus an 845-square-foot finished attic—includes a living room with a wood-burning fireplace, an adjacent parlor, a library with built-in custom shelving, and an eat-in kitchen with stainless steel appliances. Details and features include pocket doors with etched glass panes, a front-porch with doubles doors connected to the vestibule, and a foyer.  The grounds are private, with a colorful flower border and a private dock. The patio offers shade and a waterview.

54 Rysam Street, $3,495,000

This Federal-style residence on 0.25 acres is 3,500-square feet with four bedrooms and five bedrooms. Professionally designed in the spirit of a Whaling Captain’s home, the house has four levels, including a mezzanine floor. It includes a living room, a sitting parlor with gas fireplace, a library, a sunny kitchen with Carrera marble countertops and Viking and Sub Zero appliances, a dining room that seats 12, and a basement with a mahogany bar. In the backyard, find a patio, a dining ares, a pergola, a pool, and a pool house with bathroom.

Sims Drive, 3,495,000

Newly constructed on Sag Harbor Cove, this three-bedroom, three-and-half bathroom modern have 2,800 square feet of living space on 0.67 acres. The residence has walls of glass throughout and a light-filled gourmet eat-in kitchen that opens to the living room, with fireplace. The second-floor master suite boasts a walk-in closet, a fireplace and a bathroom offering pondviews. The top level was a wraparound rooftop terrace for lounging. The grounds have a spacious deck, a heated gunite spa and an outdoor kitchen with a built-in barbecue. Deep water dock permits are in place.