Why Hasn’t Anyone Bought This Georgica House in Four Years?

georgica house

We don’t get it. A charming vintage Georgica house (c. 1900) set on 1.1 acres of prime  land. Pretty landscaping, a cool round pool, but no one wants it. This house wowed us back in 2013, when it first hit the market asking $10.5M. It didn’t wow the buyers, and the price gradually dropped close to what the owner, writer Barbara Goldsmith, paid for the place back in 2006: $7.5M.

All photos via Compass

Unfortunately Ms. Goldsmith passed away last year, and now the property, repped by Ed Petrie, James Petrie, and Julie Wolfe at Compass, is a mere $5.395 million, about half what it was asking four years ago. Yes, some of the interiors need a bit of updating, but nothing really serious. Come on, people.

The house is a 5000 square foot traditional style with five bedrooms and 4.5 bathrooms. The interiors, decorated by Mica Ertegun, are gracious and elegant yet accessible. We love the kitchen with a Garland stove (for serious cooks) and a black stainless range hood. Outside, the pool really does look (at least in the picture) like a natural pond. Next to it is a pool house with a bar with refrigerator and icemaker, a bathroom and changing room, and a heated outdoor rain shower. Over the detached garage is a two bedroom cottage with its own generator.

What are you waiting for, rich folks? We’re getting close to land value here.

For more, click here. 86 Georgica Road, East Hampton.

More from our Sister Sites