Seasonal Rentals Legislation Signed Into Law

28 Wainscott Hollow Road, Wainscott
The property at 28 Wainscott Hollow Road in Wainscott is available for rent for summer 2022 with Frank and Dawn Bodenchak of Sotheby’s International Realty. The prices: $50,000 for May, $90,000 for June and $150,000 for July.
Courtesy of Sotheby’s International Realty

Landlords of seasonal rentals in the Hamptons can, legally, collect security and advance payments thanks to a law that rights an unintended consequence of earlier housing legislation reforms.

Assemblyman Fred W. Thiele Jr. announced last week that legislation he wrote to clarify that certain seasonal rentals are excluded from the provisions regulating deposits and advances for residential dwelling units under the Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act of 2019 (HSTPA), has officially been signed into law. The bill takes effect immediately.

In a statement, Thiele explains that it is common practice on the East End and in other vacation destinations to require a single payment for the entire term of the seasonal rental. “If the act were to be applied to seasonal use rentals, that practice would not be permitted,” the statement continues. “This new law will make clear that the provisions of the HSTPA relating to security and advances does not apply to rentals of registered seasonal use dwelling units.”

The HSTPA provided housing reforms intended to protect tenants in relation to permanent residential housing and was not intended to apply to seasonal rentals, Thiele says.

One provision in the HSTPA prohibited landlords from requiring a “deposit or advance” in excess of one month’s rent. Some argued that the limitation could also be applied to seasonal use tenancies. The State Attorney General, responsible for enforcing the law, did not offer an opinion on whether the act would apply to seasonal use rentals, but it nonetheless left landlords and rental agents in a quandary.

Timothy Kelly, who is the Douglas Elliman Real Estate branch manager for Sag Harbor and Montauk, says the HSTPA was meant to protect permanent tenants. The landlord is only able to collect only one month’s security deposit in advance. term rentals in the Hamptons are a different story.
“Since the rental period is sometimes one to three months, the utilities stay in the homeowner’s name and the security can be more than one month’s rent due to excess services or cost. Also the house is furnished with all the household items so you would need to collect more security. The houses are not rented vacant,” he says.
Typically landlords of seasonal rentals collected a single payment for the entire rental term and security/utility deposits, Kelly continues. “This common business practice is pertinent to the real estate income and the local economy.  The tenants can leave after one month and then it is impossible to find a tenant for the short seasonal term,” he says. “We do not have time to re-rent the property as many leases are signed way in advance. Our season is short for the summer when most people want to rent and if the tenant vacates with one month paid it is difficult to re-rent the property in time for the seasonal rental.”
Thiele agreed. “Summer rentals are a vital part of the local economy on the East End,” he says. “A change in well-accepted business practices of requiring a single payment for a seasonal rental would adversely affect the real estate market and our economy.”

Thiele introduced the new bill in February to right the wrong.

There are some conditions exempting seasonal rentals from the HSTPA, however. The tenants of such rentals must have a primary residence to return to with that address listed in the lease.  The seasonal rental also must be registered with the appropriate local government, county or state registry and cannot rented for more than 120 days in each calendar year.

Judi Desiderio, the CEO of Town & Country Real Estate, who wrote to Thiele, then Governor Andrew Cuomo and other lawmakers in February 2020 with her concerns about the issues the HSTPA caused. The new law still has flaws, she says, pointing to the rental registry requirement, which she says not every town has.

“That’s ridiculously limiting and unattainable for some,” she says, adding that Southampton Town has a rental permit, but no registry while East Hampton Town has a registry but no rental permit.

Thiele thanked Governor Kathy Hochul “for recognizing that these types of short-term tenancies require a different regulatory approach than permanent dwellings by signing this important legislation into law.”

The legislation was sponsored in the Senate by State Senator Brian Kavanagh. It passed both houses in June.

In December 2020, Thiele also fought to exclude seasonal rentals from the Emergency Eviction and Foreclosure Prevention Act. In July, he also voted against the Tenants Safe Harbor Act calling it “over-broad by including seasonal rentals utilized for vacation purposes, which were not primary residences.” It led, he said later that year, to well-documented cases of abuse on the East End.

“The exclusion of seasonal rentals from the Emergency Eviction and Foreclosure Prevention Act recognizes that these types of short-term tenancies require a different regulatory approach than permanent dwellings,” he said at the time.

Email with further comments, questions, or tips. Follow Behind The Hedges on TwitterInstagram, and Facebook.