Historic Water Mill Compound on Nearly 5 Acres Asking $4.5 Million

historic Water Mill home
Rise Media / Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Realty

A historic home in Water Mill, on a compound that has been in one family for generations, is now on the market, asking $4.5 million.

“Originally built in 1895, this is a beautiful and historic home that’s been in the same family since the 1930s,” says listing agent Edward Mulderrig of Douglas Elliman of the house at 1728 Montauk Highway.

“While the house was totally renovated and expanded, they were able to match the style of the original house and carried it through both inside and out, so all of its historic charm remains,” he explains.

The 3,700-square-foot house sits on 4.5 acres with a pool and guest house. The well-maintained property’s large backyard abuts woods, making it feel very private, Mulderrig adds.

Water Mill, historic
An aerial view of the propertyRise Media / Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Realty

“With a guest house, pool and room in the two garages for seven cars, there is plenty of space for family, guests, and entertaining. Acreage like this is also hard to find. There is room for tennis, and lots of opportunity to expand and truly make this estate your own,” he continues.

The main home, originally built in 1895, features four bedrooms and three bathrooms and was completely renovated and expanded in 1997.

An elegant entrance leads to a large, sunlit parlor and a generously-sized family room. There is also a private office space on the first floor.

The large open kitchen features granite countertops and stainless steel appliances. There is a separate formal dining room, as well.

Inside the guest houseRise Media / Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Realty

French doors in the kitchen open to an oversize patio with a 16-by-32-foot pool. Steps lead down to the rolling lawn.

Up on the second floor is where the primary bedroom can be found. The large en suite includes a walk-in closet and an expansive private deck overlooking the backyard. Three guest bedrooms are also on the second floor.

The compound also offers a 682-square-foot guest house with a full kitchen, bathroom, bedroom, laundry room and living area, as well as a backyard of its own.

The poolRise Media / Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Realty

Another outbuilding on the property can be used as an office or a gym.

In addition, there are two separate detached garages, one which has room for four cars, while the other can fit three.

1728 Montauk Highway, Water Mill, NY | $4,500,000 | Agent: Edward Mulderrig

[Listing: 1728 Montauk Highway, Water Mill | Broker: Edward Mulderrig, Douglas Elliman] GMAP

Email tvecsey@danspapers.com with further comments, questions, or tips. Follow Behind The Hedges on Twitter, Instagram, and Facebook.

The main houseRise Media / Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Realty
The entrance in the main homeRise Media / Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Realty
The kitchenRise Media / Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Realty
The dining roomRise Media / Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Realty
The living roomRise Media / Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Realty
The living roomRise Media / Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Realty
The master bedroomRise Media / Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Realty
The guest houseRise Media / Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Realty
The guest house living and dining roomRise Media / Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Realty
The backyard behind the guest houseRise Media / Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Realty
Rise Media / Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Realty
Rise Media / Courtesy of Douglas Elliman Realty

More from our Sister Sites